Back to Articles
256A2027 Q1PrimeJGAAP

TOBISHIMA HOLDINGS (256A) FY2027 Q1 Earnings Report

For FY2027 Q1, revenue came to ¥30.2B (+1.1% year on year) and operating income ¥1.6B (+5.1%). The segment drivers and cash flow follow.

Construction & Materials/Construction


Quick View

MetricCurrent PeriodPrevious Year PeriodYoY
Revenue¥302.4B¥299.1B+1.1%
Operating Income¥16.2B¥15.5B+5.1%
Ordinary Income¥14.9B¥14.0B+6.8%
Net Income¥10.0B¥11.6B−14.0%
ROE1.9%2.1%-

Executive Summary

Although revenue and operating income increased in Q1 FY2027, net income declined due to the absence of a temporary factor recorded in the previous year and a higher tax burden. Revenue was ¥302.4B (+1.1% YoY), operating income was ¥16.2B (+5.1%), and ordinary income was ¥14.9B (+6.8%). Meanwhile, net income attributable to owners of the parent was ¥10.2B (-13.4%), mainly due to the absence of the ¥1.3B gain on negative goodwill recognized in the previous year and an increase in the effective tax rate (21%→34%). The gross profit margin improved to 13.5% from 12.4% in the previous year, indicating a steady strengthening of core earnings power.

Factors Affecting Results

【Revenue】Revenue increased slightly by 1.1% YoY to ¥302.4B. By segment, A0Construction (Civil Engineering Business, ¥114.7B, -1.0%) and A0Engineering (Building Construction Business, ¥131.5B, -9.7%) posted declines in revenue, while A0GrowthBusinessAndOther (¥86.0B, +14.2%) led the increase and contributed to overall revenue growth. Revenue from government agencies was ¥12,104M, while revenue from private-sector customers was ¥17,772M, indicating an increase in the private-sector ratio.

【Profit and Loss】Operating income increased 5.1% YoY to ¥16.2B, mainly due to the improvement in the gross profit margin to 13.5% from 12.4% in the previous year. Operating income at A0Construction improved significantly by 22.6% to ¥9.1B, with its margin also rising to 7.9%. In contrast, despite revenue growth, A0GrowthBusinessAndOther posted operating income of ¥5.0B (-14.9%), with its margin declining to 5.9%, suggesting a possible investment-led phase. Ordinary income increased steadily by 6.8% to ¥14.9B, while net income declined 14.0% to ¥10.2B. The absence of the previous year’s extraordinary gain (¥1.31B gain on negative goodwill) and the increase in the effective tax rate (approximately 34%, based on income taxes of ¥5.2B and profit before tax of ¥15.2B) created a divergence between ordinary income and net income. In conclusion, the Company achieved revenue and operating profit growth at the operating and ordinary income levels, but net income declined due to the absence of a temporary factor.

Segment Analysis

The largest core segment by segment profit is A0Engineering (Building Construction Business), which maintained the highest level company-wide with operating income of ¥11.2B and an 8.5% margin. A0Construction (Civil Engineering Business) recorded lower revenue of ¥114.7B (-1.0%), but operating income improved 22.6% to ¥9.1B and its margin improved to 7.9%, suggesting progress in cost control and project profitability. A0GrowthBusinessAndOther was the only segment to achieve revenue growth, with revenue of ¥86.0B (+14.2%), but operating income declined 14.9% to ¥5.0B and its margin fell to 5.9%, acting as a factor diluting the Company-wide margin despite its revenue growth. Corporate expenses (adjustments) were -¥9.0B, broadly unchanged from -¥8.8B in the previous year.

Key Financial Metrics

【Profitability】The operating margin improved to 5.4% from 5.2% in the previous year, and the gross profit margin also rose to 13.5% from 12.4%. However, the net profit margin declined to 3.4% from 3.9%. 【Cash Quality】Accounts receivable from completed construction contracts declined significantly to ¥652.9B from ¥801.4B in the previous year, indicating progress in receivables collection, while advances received on construction contracts in progress remained broadly stable at ¥77.8B (+1.9%). 【Investment Efficiency】ROE was 1.9%, and the equity ratio was 36.6% (33.3% in the previous year). With a low total asset turnover ratio, capital efficiency remains limited. 【Financial Soundness】Short-term borrowings were significantly reduced by 37.6% YoY to ¥190.0B, while total assets contracted to ¥1454.8B from ¥1631.0B, indicating progress in restraining financial leverage.

Cash Flow Analysis

Although the disclosure does not include detailed cash flow statements, changes in the balance sheet provide insight into funding trends. Accounts receivable from completed construction contracts declined to ¥652.9B from ¥801.4B, indicating the release of cash from working capital. Meanwhile, short-term borrowings declined substantially to ¥190.0B from ¥305.0B in the previous year (-37.6%), suggesting that funds were allocated to debt repayment. Cash and deposits increased to ¥225.3B from ¥208.7B in the previous year. Maintaining cash levels while progressing with receivables collection and debt repayment in parallel indicates sound cash management. Capital expenditures were modest, with property, plant and equipment broadly flat at ¥253.8B versus ¥253.6B in the previous year, and no significant investment burden arose.

Quality of Earnings

The core of recurring earnings power in the current period was operating income of ¥16.2B. Non-operating income of ¥0.6B (including ¥0.2B in dividend income) and non-operating expenses of ¥1.9B (including ¥1.4B in interest expense) were small, resulting in an earnings structure highly dependent on the core business. Extraordinary items were limited to extraordinary income of ¥0.3B, including a ¥0.2B gain on the sale of investment securities. In the previous year, however, the Company recorded extraordinary income of ¥1.3B, including a ¥1.3B gain on negative goodwill, and the absence of this temporary factor was one of the main causes of the decline in net income. The divergence between ordinary income of ¥14.9B and net income of ¥10.2B was primarily attributable to the higher tax burden. Income taxes of ¥5.2B represented an effective tax rate of approximately 34% against profit before tax of ¥15.2B, up from 21% in the previous year. Comprehensive income was ¥7.4B, below net income of ¥10.2B, mainly due to deterioration in the valuation difference on securities (-¥2.4B). Accordingly, comprehensive income for the current period was more conservative than net income.

Earnings Forecast and Guidance

Q1 progress against the full-year forecast was 20.2% for revenue (¥302.4B/¥1,500B), 20.3% for operating income (¥16.2B/¥80.0B), and 21.3% for ordinary income (¥14.9B/¥70.0B), all below the simple one-quarter benchmark of 25%. The construction industry has seasonal characteristics, with construction progress weighted toward the second half of the fiscal year; therefore, these progress rates do not necessarily indicate a risk of downward revisions. As of the current quarter, the Company has not revised either its earnings forecast or dividend forecast. The full-year plan anticipates revenue growth of +7.7% and operating income growth of +15.8%, with achievement depending on the accumulation of construction progress in the second half and improved profitability in the Growth Business.

Shareholder Returns

The full-year dividend forecast is ¥110 per share, implying a payout ratio of approximately 44.0% based on full-year forecast EPS of ¥250.11. As of the current quarter, the dividend forecast has not been revised. Based on approximately 19.19M shares outstanding, excluding treasury shares, total annual dividends are expected to be approximately ¥21.1B, a well-covered level relative to cash and deposits of ¥225.3B. Treasury shares were ¥0.33B, down from ¥0.79B in the previous year, and no large-scale share repurchases have been identified.

Risk Factors

  1. Dependence on short-term liabilities: Short-term borrowings were reduced to ¥190.0B (-37.6% from the previous year), but the proportion of short-term debt within total interest-bearing debt remains high, and changes in refinancing conditions could affect funding costs.

  2. Changes in the profitability mix among segments: A0GrowthBusinessAndOther achieved revenue growth of +14.2%, but operating income declined by -14.9% and its margin fell to 5.9%, exerting a dilutive effect on the Company-wide profit margin.

  3. Variability in the tax burden and temporary factors: The effective tax rate increased to approximately 34% from approximately 21% in the previous year. In addition, the ¥1.3B gain on negative goodwill recognized in the previous year was absent in the current period, placing pressure on net income relative to the growth in ordinary income.

Industry Benchmark (For Reference; Compiled by the Company)

Profitability and Returns

MetricCompanyMedian (IQR)Delta
Operating Margin5.4%4.5% (2.7%–6.6%)+0.9pt
Net Profit Margin3.3%3.8% (-1.1%–4.4%)−0.5pt

The operating margin exceeds the industry median, while the net profit margin is below the median due to the higher tax burden and the absence of temporary factors.

Growth and Capital Efficiency

MetricCompanyMedian (IQR)Delta
Revenue Growth Rate (YoY)1.1%4.8% (3.4%–10.1%)−3.7pt

The revenue growth rate is significantly below the industry median, indicating that the pace of top-line expansion is relatively moderate within the industry.

Source: Compiled by the Company

Key Points from the Financial Results

  1. Through improved gross profit in the core businesses (civil engineering and building construction) and SG&A expense control, the operating margin improved to 5.4%, exceeding the industry median of 4.5%. Whether this improvement resulted from materials prices and cost management or from a temporary effect of the project mix will be an important point to assess in future quarters.

  2. The decline in net income was primarily attributable to factors unrelated to operating performance, namely the absence of the previous year’s gain on negative goodwill and the increase in the effective tax rate. The 6.8% increase in ordinary income is therefore an important point in understanding the earnings structure.

  3. The Company reduced short-term borrowings by 37.6% from the previous year while maintaining its cash position, indicating ongoing deleveraging of its financial structure. Meanwhile, the revenue increase and profit decline at A0GrowthBusinessAndOther should be monitored as a structural change that may indicate either an investment-led phase or challenges in monetization.

Theoretical Share Price (Reference Value)

This is a mechanically calculated reference range based solely on publicly disclosed data using a residual income model (Ohlson-type model with an explicit 5-year fade). It is not a forecast of the market share price or a recommendation of any specific investment action.

ScenarioTheoretical Share Price
bear¥2,713
base¥2,794
bull¥2,853
Calculation AssumptionValue
Book Value per Share (BPS)¥2,770
Adjusted Forecast EPS¥279.3
Cost of Equity r9.77% (10-year government bond 2.77% + equity risk premium 6.00% + size premium 1.00%)
Residual Income Persistence Coefficient ω / Explicit Forecast Period0.62 / 5 years
Assumed Payout Ratio44.0%
Forecast EPS Confidence Adjustment×1.117 (based on the track record of guidance achievement in the same industry)
Implied PBR / PER1.01x / 10.0x

Sensitivity: ¥2,718–¥2,874 at ±1% in the cost of equity, and ¥2,794–¥2,795 at ±0.1 in ω.

Notes:

  • Net assets as of the quarter-end were used; there is a timing difference relative to the full-year forecast.
  • Since net assets include non-controlling interests, the theoretical value may be calculated somewhat higher.

(Calculation model: Residual income model / Interest rate reference month: 2026-07 / This value does not forecast or guarantee the future share price)


This report is an earnings analysis document automatically generated by AI based on XBRL earnings release data. It does not recommend investment in any specific security. The industry benchmarks are reference information compiled by the Company based on publicly disclosed earnings data. Investment decisions should be made at your own discretion and responsibility, after consulting professionals as necessary.

---End of Report---


AI Financial Analysis

Executive Summary

FY2027 Q1 showed modest top-line growth and improved operating profitability, but lower attributable profit reduced the quality of the headline result. Revenue increased 1.1% YoY to ¥30.24bn. Operating income rose 5.1% to ¥1.62bn, outpacing sales growth. Gross profit increased 10.2% to ¥4.09bn despite broadly flat construction revenue. The gross margin expanded by 111bp YoY to 13.5%. Operating margin improved by 20bp to 5.4%. Ordinary income increased 6.8% to ¥1.49bn and its margin widened by 26bp to 4.9%. In contrast, profit attributable to owners fell 13.4% to ¥1.02bn. Net margin contracted by 56bp YoY to 3.4%. The principal bridge from higher ordinary income to lower net income was a materially higher effective tax rate of 34.1%, versus roughly 21.2% in the prior-year quarter, together with a lower level of extraordinary gains. Prior-year net income had also benefited from a ¥131m gain on negative goodwill, while current-year extraordinary income was only ¥26m, mainly gains on sales of securities and assets. Civil engineering remained the core business by segment profit contribution, generating ¥1.12bn of profit. Building construction delivered the strongest segment-profit growth, while Growth Businesses and Others posted strong revenue expansion but lower segment profit. The reported annualized ROE was 7.6%, below the 8% reference threshold, indicating that profitability remains modest relative to the capital employed. Balance-sheet liquidity is adequate, with a 129.8% current ratio and cash equivalent to 1.19x short-term borrowings. However, 74.7% of interest-bearing debt matures within one year, making refinancing execution and construction-related cash collection important monitoring points. Full-year guidance implies Q1 operating-income progress of 20.3%, modestly below the standard 25% first-quarter run rate but consistent with construction-sector project timing and seasonal completion patterns. Management maintained both earnings and dividend guidance.

Profitability Analysis

The reported annualized DuPont ROE of 7.6% is decomposed into a 3.4% net profit margin, 0.832x annualized asset turnover, and 2.74x financial leverage. Financial leverage is the largest numerical contributor to ROE, whereas the low net margin is the principal constraint on shareholder returns. The operating margin improved to 5.4% from approximately 5.2% in the prior-year quarter, supported by gross-margin expansion to 13.5% from 12.4%. Cost of sales declined 0.2% YoY despite 1.1% revenue growth, indicating improved project-level cost absorption and/or a more favorable project mix. SG&A expenses increased 13.9% to ¥2.47bn, substantially faster than revenue growth. Consequently, the SG&A-to-sales ratio rose by 91bp to 8.2%, absorbing most of the gross-margin improvement and limiting operating-margin expansion to 20bp. Civil engineering revenue declined 9.7% to ¥13.15bn, but segment profit increased 2.2% to ¥1.12bn; its segment margin improved by 98bp to 8.5%. Building construction revenue was broadly stable, down 1.0% to ¥11.47bn, while segment profit rose 22.6% to ¥0.91bn and margin expanded by 152bp to 7.9%. Growth Businesses and Others revenue rose 49.3% to ¥5.62bn, but segment profit declined 14.9% to ¥0.50bn, reducing its margin by 673bp to 9.0%. This indicates that the rapid expansion in Growth Businesses and Others has not yet translated proportionately into earnings. Interest coverage of 11.28x remains sound, and the 0.935 interest burden indicates that financing costs are not currently a major drag on pre-tax profitability. The tax burden of 0.668 was below the 0.70 reference level, reflecting the elevated effective tax rate and explaining why improved EBIT and ordinary income did not translate into net-income growth.

Growth Assessment

Revenue growth of 1.1% was modest, with the business mix shifting away from public-sector construction toward private-sector and Growth Businesses and Others activity. Public-sector revenue declined 12.4% YoY to ¥12.10bn, led by lower civil-engineering public work. Private-sector revenue increased 12.4% to ¥17.77bn, supported by civil engineering and Growth Businesses and Others. The revenue mix therefore became more private-sector oriented, with private-sector revenue representing 59% of total revenue versus 53% a year earlier. Building construction was resilient despite a 1.0% revenue decline, as segment-margin recovery drove a substantial profit increase. Civil engineering profitability also improved despite weaker revenue, suggesting enhanced execution on the projects recognized during the quarter. Growth Businesses and Others expanded rapidly but exhibited material margin dilution, making the earnings quality of this growth less compelling than the construction segments' margin improvement. Full-year guidance calls for revenue growth of 7.7% to ¥150.0bn and operating-income growth of 15.8% to ¥8.0bn. Q1 progress against guidance was 20.2% for revenue, 20.3% for operating income, 21.3% for ordinary income, and 21.1% for attributable profit. These progress rates are 3.7-4.8 percentage points below a simple 25% first-quarter benchmark, but not by more than the 10-percentage-point threshold that would signal a material deviation. Construction revenue and profit recognition are inherently dependent on project completion schedules, so quarterly run rates should not be extrapolated mechanically. The ¥0.97bn provision for loss on construction contracts is a relevant indicator of project-execution risk, although it declined from ¥1.21bn in the prior-year quarter. Sustainable growth will depend on converting the improved private-sector mix and higher building margins into full-year delivery without further margin dilution in Growth Businesses and Others.

Financial Health

Liquidity is adequate but not abundant for a construction group with substantial project-related current liabilities. Current assets of ¥107.62bn exceeded current liabilities of ¥82.92bn, producing working capital of ¥24.70bn and a current ratio of 129.8%. The quick ratio was also 129.8%, indicating that reported liquidity is not reliant on inventory liquidation. Cash and deposits were ¥22.53bn, equal to 1.19x short-term loans of ¥19.00bn. Interest-bearing debt totaled ¥25.45bn, comprising ¥19.00bn of short-term loans and ¥6.45bn of long-term loans. Short-term loans declined ¥11.45bn, or 37.6%, YoY, which materially strengthened the immediate debt profile. Nevertheless, the short-term debt ratio remains high at 74.7%, triggering the refinancing-risk alert. The root cause is the concentration of debt maturities in short-term facilities rather than the absolute debt level alone. This structure can be common in construction, where working-capital needs fluctuate with progress billings, advances received, and receivable collections, but it leaves liquidity more exposed to timing mismatches and bank-funding conditions. The impact is that delayed customer collections or a rise in funding costs could require renewed short-term borrowing and pressure financial flexibility. The reported debt-to-equity ratio of 1.74x remains below the 2.0x aggressive-leverage warning threshold, while interest-bearing debt is equivalent to a more modest 0.48x of total equity. Debt-to-capital of 32.4% is also within the sub-40% investment-grade reference range. Total liabilities decreased ¥16.39bn YoY, faster than the ¥1.23bn reduction in equity, improving the capital adequacy ratio to 36.5% from 33.3%. Construction receivables declined ¥14.85bn to ¥65.29bn, which has supported the lower asset and funding base. Advances received on uncompleted construction rose to ¥7.79bn, providing some project funding support, while deposits received declined to ¥29.60bn.

Notable B/S Changes

Total assets: -¥17.62bn (-10.8%) YoY to ¥145.48bn, primarily reflecting lower current assets and construction receivables; this indicates a smaller working-capital base. Construction receivables: -¥14.85bn (-18.5%) YoY to ¥65.29bn, supportive of collection efficiency and lower funding needs, subject to normal construction project-timing effects. Short-term loans: -¥11.45bn (-37.6%) YoY to ¥19.00bn, materially improving near-term leverage; however, short-term debt still represents 74.7% of total interest-bearing debt. Total liabilities: -¥16.39bn (-15.1%) YoY to ¥92.30bn, a faster reduction than equity and supportive of the increase in capital adequacy to 36.5%. Treasury stock: increased by ¥0.46bn from -¥0.79bn to -¥0.33bn, reducing the treasury-share deduction within equity.

Cash Flow Quality

The balance-sheet movement points to improved working-capital discipline during the quarter. Construction receivables decreased by ¥14.85bn YoY, or 18.5%, to ¥65.29bn. This reduction is supportive of operating cash conversion if it reflects collection of completed-contract receivables rather than only changes in project-recognition timing. Short-term borrowings decreased by ¥11.45bn YoY while cash and deposits increased by ¥1.66bn to ¥22.53bn, a combination consistent with a stronger near-term funding position. Advances received on uncompleted construction increased by ¥0.14bn to ¥7.79bn, which is favorable for project financing because customer advances reduce the cash burden before completion. Conversely, deposits received decreased by ¥1.76bn and trade payables declined by ¥3.36bn YoY, which may partly offset cash released from receivables. The provision for loss on construction contracts fell ¥0.24bn to ¥0.97bn, reducing the balance-sheet reserve for anticipated loss-making projects while remaining material relative to quarterly operating income. The elevated tax charge was the primary reason that attributable profit did not follow the increase in ordinary income. The small ¥26m extraordinary gain did not materially inflate current-quarter earnings. Overall earnings quality is better characterized by operating-margin improvement than by net-income growth, because the latter was distorted by tax and comparative non-recurring items. Working-capital collection trends, construction-loss provisions, and the ability to maintain lower short-term debt should be monitored as the key cash-conversion indicators.

Dividend Sustainability

The full-year dividend forecast is ¥110 per share, unchanged from management's prior guidance. Against forecast EPS of ¥250.11, the implied dividend payout ratio is 44.0%. This is below the 60% sustainability benchmark and leaves capacity for retained earnings, debt reduction, and project-related working-capital requirements. The forecast dividend represents a cash commitment of approximately ¥2.11bn based on 19.23 million issued shares. Forecast attributable profit of ¥4.80bn would cover this dividend commitment by approximately 2.3x. Retained earnings of ¥441.86bn provide a substantial equity buffer relative to the expected annual dividend. The current balance-sheet structure nevertheless makes dividend sustainability partly dependent on continued discipline over short-term funding and construction-receivable collection. The reduction in short-term loans and increase in cash are supportive of dividend capacity. No dividend revision was announced with the first-quarter results. The sustainability of the stated dividend policy should be assessed primarily against full-year profit delivery, project cash conversion, and refinancing conditions rather than Q1 EPS alone.

Risk Assessment

Business risks include Construction-project execution risk: the ¥0.97bn provision for loss on construction contracts demonstrates ongoing exposure to cost overruns, design changes, subcontractor issues, and fixed-price contract losses., Margin risk: the 13.5% gross margin triggers the low-gross-margin alert because a relatively narrow gross-profit buffer leaves earnings sensitive to labor, materials, equipment, and subcontractor-cost inflation. Although the margin improved 111bp YoY, it remains below the 20% reference threshold and requires continued project-selectivity discipline., Growth Businesses and Others profitability risk: revenue increased 49.3% YoY but segment profit declined 14.9%, with margin falling to 9.0% from 15.7%. This suggests that expansion, integration, or business-mix effects may be dilutive until profitability normalizes., Demand-mix risk: public-sector revenue fell 12.4% YoY, increasing reliance on private-sector projects, which can be more sensitive to corporate capital-expenditure cycles and real-estate market conditions., Industry-specific risk: shortages of skilled construction labor, higher wages, volatile steel/cement/material costs, weather disruptions, and stricter safety requirements can delay projects and erode margins, particularly on fixed-price contracts..

Financial risks include Refinancing risk: 74.7% of interest-bearing debt is short term. The root cause is a ¥19.00bn short-term loan balance versus ¥25.45bn total interest-bearing debt. While this can reflect normal construction working-capital financing and cash covers 1.19x of short-term loans, funding availability and customer-collection timing remain material to liquidity., Leverage sensitivity: reported debt-to-equity is 1.74x. This is below the 2.0x aggressive-leverage threshold and interest coverage is strong at 11.28x, but a higher interest-rate environment would raise the cost of rolling short-term facilities., Comprehensive-income volatility: comprehensive income was ¥0.74bn, below attributable profit of ¥1.02bn, as valuation differences on securities reduced other comprehensive income..

Key concerns include Whether building and civil-engineering margin gains can be sustained through the full year while SG&A growth of 13.9% remains well above 1.1% revenue growth., Whether the lower gross-margin profile can absorb renewed material and labor-cost inflation without additional construction-loss provisions., Whether Growth Businesses and Others can restore margins while maintaining its high revenue-growth rate., Whether lower short-term debt can be maintained through seasonal construction working-capital movements and project completion cycles., Whether Q1 progress of approximately 20-21% against full-year profit guidance accelerates as expected in subsequent quarters..

Investment Implications

Key takeaways include Operating earnings improved faster than sales, with operating income up 5.1% YoY and gross margin up 111bp., Net income fell 13.4% YoY because of a 34.1% effective tax rate and the absence of the prior year's larger non-recurring gains., Civil engineering is the core business by segment profit, while building construction supplied the strongest profit growth and margin recovery., Growth Businesses and Others delivered the highest sales growth but lower profits, making segment-margin recovery central to the group earnings thesis., Liquidity is sufficient and short-term loans fell sharply, but the 74.7% short-term debt ratio remains a material refinancing and cash-timing consideration., The ¥110 forecast DPS implies a 44.0% dividend payout ratio against forecast EPS, which is consistent with a sustainable dividend framework if full-year guidance is delivered..

Metrics to watch include Full-year operating-income guidance progress versus the ¥8.0bn target, Gross margin and SG&A-to-sales ratio, particularly whether SG&A growth moderates, Civil engineering and building construction segment margins, Growth Businesses and Others revenue growth versus segment-profit and margin recovery, Provision for loss on construction contracts, Construction receivables, advances received, deposits received, and short-term loan balances, Short-term debt ratio and interest coverage, Public-sector versus private-sector construction revenue mix.

Regarding relative positioning, The group presents a mixed construction-sector profile: operating margins are improving and interest coverage is strong, but the 13.5% gross margin remains modest, annualized ROE of 7.6% is below the 8% reference level, and funding is more short-term weighted than a conservatively financed peer. The balance-sheet reduction in short-term loans is a positive differentiator, while the earnings contribution from rapidly expanding Growth Businesses and Others requires margin validation.